The Colonial Panopticon

Wearing the Dead

Alias Grace | The Orphan's Archive & The Domestic Panopticon

Pedagogical Framework

If the nomad "sheds skins" to find freedom, the orphan must "wear the dead" to survive. This unit complements the Ondaatje unit, and examines Grace Marks as the orphan of Empire—an Irish immigrant subject marginalized by English Loyalist elites following the 1837 Rebellion, who navigates the rigid legal and medical structures of Victorian Canada by stitching together a patchwork identity from the memories and clothes of the deceased. Bridging the IB Diploma Program English Literature focus on fragmented perspective and unreliable narration with Undergraduate Literary & Critical Theory shift to engage Foucault 's notions of Biopolitics and the Panopticon, and the impact on multivalent cultural negotiations with power.

Theoretical Anchors

Michel Foucault: Biopolitics & The Docile Body
We explore the Penitentiary and the Asylum as sites where the "orphan" body is governed. Grace’s "silence" is framed as a resistance against the biopolitical urge to categorize her as either murderess or victim.

Giorgio Agamben: Bare Life
Positioning Grace in the state of "inclusive exclusion." As an immigrant without standing, she is reduced to "bare life"—a body that can be punished but not heard, existing only in the "skin" the state allows her.

The 1837 Rebellion: Colonial Hegemony
Analyzing the novel's setting against the failed democratic uprisings. We examine how the "English" legal structures in Canada were designed to suppress the Irish/Scots immigrant classes viewed as a threat to loyalist order.

Patchwork Stylistics: Constructing the Archive
Quilting functions as a counter-hegemonic strategy. We analyze Grace’s unreliable narrative as a way of "weaving" a history that destabilizes the "striated" official record of the colonial press.

Research Synthesis

Pradip Sharma

(Bio)Political Violence
Explores how Grace is subjected to institutional power designed to formulate docility, reducing her to "bare life" within the colonial state.
View Full PDF

Historical Context

The 1837 Rebellion
Details the social division between loyalist English elites and marginalized immigrants, framing Grace's trial as a political performance.
View Full PDF

Pedagogical Plan

Stylistics & Sovereignty
Outlines the use of unreliable narration and patchwork structure to interrogate how marginalized identities are "governed" in 19th-century Canada.
View Full PDF

Global Discourse

Margaret Atwood: On Alias Grace — The author discusses the unreliability of the 19th-century archive and the construction of the "Murderess." Elizabeth Loftus: The Fiction of Memory — A cognitive lens on how trauma and suggestion reconstruct the past. Foucault & The Panopticon — Understanding the architecture of surveillance and disciplinary power.

Unit Deliverables

Download Diploma Program Resources Download Undergraduate Resources